‘One Nation, One Election’ Bill Introduced in the Lok Sabha; 269 Members Vote in Favor, 198 Against

‘One Nation, One Election’ Bill Introduced in the Lok Sabha; 269 Members Vote in Favor, 198 Against

Titas Mukherjee     Dec 17, 2024 03:09 pm

The Constitution (One Hundred and Twenty-Ninth Amendment) Bill, 2024 and the Union Territories Laws (Amendment) Bill, 2024 were formally introduced in the Lok Sabha on Tuesday after members voted on their presentation. These bills propose the idea of "One Nation, One Election," aiming for simultaneous elections to the Lok Sabha and state assemblies. After the introduction, the bills were sent to a Joint Parliamentary Committee (JPC) for detailed discussions.

During the debate, opposition members demanded a vote on the introduction of the bills. The motion to introduce the legislation was moved by Law Minister Arjun Ram Meghwal, who later agreed to send the bills to a JPC, as suggested by Union Home Minister Amit Shah. Following the vote, 269 members supported the introduction, while 198 members opposed it. Meghwal officially introduced the Constitution (129th Amendment) Bill, 2024 on the concept of "One Nation, One Election," and stated that the bills would be forwarded to the JPC as per the Prime Minister's earlier suggestion.

The bills also propose amendments to several key laws. These include changes to the Government of Union Territories Act (1963), the Government of National Capital Territory of Delhi Act (1991), and the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act (2019). These amendments aim to align the election timelines in Delhi, Jammu and Kashmir, and Puducherry with the proposed simultaneous elections.

Opposition parties, however, strongly opposed the bills. Congress MP Manish Tewari criticized the move, arguing that the proposed amendments would undermine the Constitution's basic structure. Similarly, DMK MP TR Baalu voiced opposition, describing the bill as "anti-federal." "The electors have the right to elect the government for five years, and this right cannot be curtailed with simultaneous elections,” said Balu.

Samajwadi Party MP Dharmendra Yadav questioned the rationale behind the bill. "I cannot understand how, just two days ago, no stone was left unturned to uphold the glorious tradition of saving the Constitution. Within two days, this Constitution Amendment Bill has been brought to undermine the basic spirit and structure of the Constitution," he said. He further added, "I agree with Manish Tewari, and on behalf of my party and my leader Akhilesh Yadav, I have no hesitation in saying that there was no one more learned than the makers of our Constitution at that time."

TMC MP Kalyan Banerjee also opposed the bills, arguing that they would compromise the federal structure. He stated, "This proposed bill hits the basic structure of the Constitution itself and if any bill affects the basic structure of the Constitution, it is ultra vires. We must remember that the state government and the state legislative assembly are not subordinate to the central government or to Parliament." Banerjee further argued that the autonomy of state assemblies would be undermined, pointing out that Parliament and state assemblies each have their own legislative powers under the Constitution. "By this process, the autonomy of the state legislative assembly is being taken away," he concluded.

Reported By: Titas Mukherjee     Place: Kolkata     Dec 17, 2024 03:09 pm




Place : Kolkata     Reported By : Titas Mukherjee     17-12-2024 03:09:10 pm

The Constitution (One Hundred and Twenty-Ninth Amendment) Bill, 2024 and the Union Territories Laws (Amendment) Bill, 2024 were formally introduced in the Lok Sabha on Tuesday after members voted on their presentation. These bills propose the idea of "One Nation, One Election," aiming for simultaneous elections to the Lok Sabha and state assemblies. After the introduction, the bills were sent to a Joint Parliamentary Committee (JPC) for detailed discussions.

During the debate, opposition members demanded a vote on the introduction of the bills. The motion to introduce the legislation was moved by Law Minister Arjun Ram Meghwal, who later agreed to send the bills to a JPC, as suggested by Union Home Minister Amit Shah. Following the vote, 269 members supported the introduction, while 198 members opposed it. Meghwal officially introduced the Constitution (129th Amendment) Bill, 2024 on the concept of "One Nation, One Election," and stated that the bills would be forwarded to the JPC as per the Prime Minister's earlier suggestion.

The bills also propose amendments to several key laws. These include changes to the Government of Union Territories Act (1963), the Government of National Capital Territory of Delhi Act (1991), and the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act (2019). These amendments aim to align the election timelines in Delhi, Jammu and Kashmir, and Puducherry with the proposed simultaneous elections.

Opposition parties, however, strongly opposed the bills. Congress MP Manish Tewari criticized the move, arguing that the proposed amendments would undermine the Constitution's basic structure. Similarly, DMK MP TR Baalu voiced opposition, describing the bill as "anti-federal." "The electors have the right to elect the government for five years, and this right cannot be curtailed with simultaneous elections,” said Balu.

Samajwadi Party MP Dharmendra Yadav questioned the rationale behind the bill. "I cannot understand how, just two days ago, no stone was left unturned to uphold the glorious tradition of saving the Constitution. Within two days, this Constitution Amendment Bill has been brought to undermine the basic spirit and structure of the Constitution," he said. He further added, "I agree with Manish Tewari, and on behalf of my party and my leader Akhilesh Yadav, I have no hesitation in saying that there was no one more learned than the makers of our Constitution at that time."

TMC MP Kalyan Banerjee also opposed the bills, arguing that they would compromise the federal structure. He stated, "This proposed bill hits the basic structure of the Constitution itself and if any bill affects the basic structure of the Constitution, it is ultra vires. We must remember that the state government and the state legislative assembly are not subordinate to the central government or to Parliament." Banerjee further argued that the autonomy of state assemblies would be undermined, pointing out that Parliament and state assemblies each have their own legislative powers under the Constitution. "By this process, the autonomy of the state legislative assembly is being taken away," he concluded.

Top Posts

1.

Two Years On, Manipur Still Bleeds: Congress Slams PM Modi for "Abdication of Duty"...

As Manipur marks two years since ethnic violence first erupted on 3 May 2023, Congress has launched ... Read more
2.

Maharashtra Govt Diverts ₹746 Crore SC/ST Welfare Funds to Ladki Bahin Scheme Amid Budget Shortfal...

Facing a deepening financial crisis, the Maharashtra government has redirected ₹746 crore original... Read more
3.

Pakistan Conducts Missile Test Amid Rising Tensions with India Following Pahalgam Attack...

Amid escalating tensions with India in the wake of the deadly Pahalgam terror attack, Pakistan on Sa... Read more
4.

PM Modi Vows Ruthless Crackdown on Terror After Pahalgam Massacre...

In the wake of last week’s deadly attack in Pahalgam that left at least 26 dead and dozens injured... Read more
5.

Pahalgam Attack Fallout: Cyber Offensives amist Rising Indo-Pak Tensions, Military on Alert...

Tensions between India and Pakistan have sharply escalated following the 22 April terrorist attack i... Read more

LATEST NEWS

1.

Two Years On, Manipur Still Bleeds: Congress Slams PM Modi for "Abdication of Duty"...

As Manipur marks two years since ethnic violence first erupted on 3 May 2023, Congress has launched ... Read more
2.

Maharashtra Govt Diverts ₹746 Crore SC/ST Welfare Funds to Ladki Bahin Scheme Amid Budget Shortfal...

Facing a deepening financial crisis, the Maharashtra government has redirected ₹746 crore original... Read more
3.

Pakistan Conducts Missile Test Amid Rising Tensions with India Following Pahalgam Attack...

Amid escalating tensions with India in the wake of the deadly Pahalgam terror attack, Pakistan on Sa... Read more
4.

PM Modi Vows Ruthless Crackdown on Terror After Pahalgam Massacre...

In the wake of last week’s deadly attack in Pahalgam that left at least 26 dead and dozens injured... Read more
5.

Pahalgam Attack Fallout: Cyber Offensives amist Rising Indo-Pak Tensions, Military on Alert...

Tensions between India and Pakistan have sharply escalated following the 22 April terrorist attack i... Read more
6.

"Hollow Leadership...": Sanjay Raut Questions PM Modi’s Crisis Response After Pahalgam Attack, Dem...

Shiv Sena (UBT) leader Sanjay Raut has launched a scathing attack on Prime Minister Narendra Modi’... Read more

Top Videos